show don't tell - abstract dark theme illustration

Show Don’t Tell: A Guide for Fiction Writers

Every new writer hears the phrase show don’t tell almost as soon as they put pen to paper. It is the golden rule that seems simple on the surface but often feels like a riddle when you are actually staring at a blank page. For those of us who love the slow build of a story, the urge to simply explain how a character feels can be strong. However, the magic of fiction happens when we stop explaining and start illustrating.

What does showing actually do for the reader?

When we tell a reader that a character is nervous, we are giving them a fact. Facts are efficient, but they are flat. They happen in the mind of the narrator, not in the heart of the reader. Showing is different because it provides the evidence. Instead of stating the emotion, we describe the physical manifestation of that feeling.

Imagine a scene where a woman is waiting for a phone call. If we write that she is anxious, the reader knows the state of her mind. If we write that she paces the length of the rug, chewing her lower lip until it bleeds, the reader feels the anxiety. They see the movement. They hear the rhythmic thud of her heels on the floor. They are no longer being told a story; they are experiencing it.

This shift moves the reader from a passive observer to an active participant. They get to play detective. When they see a character avoid eye contact or grip a steering wheel until their knuckles turn white, they conclude that the character is lying or stressed. That act of discovery creates a bond between the reader and the page. It makes the story feel true.

The problem with emotional labels

One of the hardest habits to break is the use of emotional labels. Words like angry, sad, happy, or terrified are shortcuts. They are useful in a first draft when you just need to get the plot down, but they often act as barriers in a final manuscript. An emotional label tells the reader how to feel, rather than making them feel it.

Consider the difference in a hypothetical snippet. One version says, “He felt a deep sense of regret as he looked at the old photograph.” This is a label. The second version says, “He traced the edge of the photograph, his finger lingering on the faded smile of the girl he had left behind. He closed his eyes and smelled the ghost of lavender perfume.”

The second version does not use the word regret, yet the emotion is far more potent. It uses sensory details to anchor the feeling in a physical object. By focusing on the action of tracing the photo and the memory of a scent, the writing bypasses the logical brain and hits the emotional center. This is why sensory detail is so important for immersive writing.

When is telling actually the right choice?

Despite the popularity of the rule, no story can be written entirely through showing. If every single action were illustrated, a novel would be ten thousand pages long and move at the speed of a snail. Telling is a tool for pacing. It allows you to skim through the mundane parts of life to reach the moments that matter.

Telling is perfect for transitions. You do not need to show a character waking up, brushing their teeth, and driving to work if nothing important happens during those hours. A simple sentence like “Three weeks passed in a blur of rainy afternoons” is far more effective than showing twenty one days of rain. It signals to the reader that these days are not the focus.

Telling also works well for background information that does not drive the immediate plot. If a character has lived in a small town for twenty years, you can state that fact quickly so you can get to the current conflict. The goal is to find a balance. Show the peaks of the story and tell the valleys. This keeps the narrative moving while ensuring the emotional beats land with full force. You can learn more about managing these peaks and valleys in this guide on story structure.

Using dialogue as a showing tool

Dialogue is one of the most effective ways to show character and tension without relying on a narrator. The way a person speaks often reveals more than what they are saying. A character who uses short, clipped sentences might be hiding something or feeling impatient. A character who rambles and repeats themselves might be desperate for approval.

Instead of telling us that two characters are fighting, let the dialogue do the work. Avoid using adverbs like “he said angrily.” Instead, let the words carry the anger. Contrast the spoken words with the physical actions. If a character says “I am perfectly fine” while shaking a glass of water until it spills, the reader knows they are lying. This creates a subtext that makes the scene feel layered and real.

The key is to avoid “on the nose” dialogue where characters state their emotions explicitly. People rarely say, “I am currently feeling very sad because you forgot my birthday.” They are more likely to say, “I see the calendar is still blank.” This approach to realistic dialogue turns a conversation into a scene of action.

Filtering words to cut during revision

As you revise your work, look for “filtering words.” These are words that remind the reader they are reading a story through a character’s eyes. Common culprits include saw, felt, heard, noticed, seemed, and realized. These words act as a lens that sits between the reader and the experience.

Compare these two sentences. The first says, “She noticed the room was cold.” The second says, “A chill seeped through her thin sweater, making her shiver.” The first sentence tells us about the character’s perception. The second sentence puts us inside the cold room.

When you remove the filter, the action becomes more immediate. Instead of writing “He heard the door slam,” try “The door slammed, echoing through the empty hallway.” The result is a tighter, more direct experience. By stripping away the narrator’s observations, you allow the reader to inhabit the character’s skin. This is a great way to increase the tension in a scene, especially when you are building conflict.

Practising the skill in revision

Mastering show don’t tell is rarely something that happens in the first draft. Most writers tell far more than they show when they are first trying to figure out the plot. The real work happens in the second and third passes. Start by scanning your manuscript for emotional adjectives. Every time you see a word like “exhausted” or “joyful,” ask yourself if there is a way to prove that feeling through action.

Try a simple exercise. Take a paragraph that is heavy on telling and rewrite it as a series of images. If you wrote “The house was creepy,” change it to “The porch swing creaked in the wind, and a single shutter hung by a rusted nail.” You will find that the word count increases, but the impact grows as well.

Remember to be patient with yourself. The goal is not to eliminate telling entirely, but to use it intentionally. Use the resources available at Reedsy and The Write Practice to find more examples of this technique in action. The more you practice, the more natural it will become.

Frequently asked questions about showing and telling

The same questions come up every time writers work through this rule. These are the short answers.

Is it wrong to tell the reader how a character feels?

It is not wrong, but it is often less effective. Telling is a shortcut. If you use it too often, the reader may feel disconnected from the character. Use telling for minor emotions and showing for the moments that define the story.

How do I know if I am showing too much?

You are showing too much if the pacing slows down to a crawl. If it takes three pages to describe a character opening a door, you have lost the momentum. Balance your vivid descriptions with efficient summary to keep the reader engaged.

Can I show internal thoughts without telling?

Yes. Instead of saying “She wondered if he loved her,” show her analyzing his silence or searching his face for a sign. Internal monologue can be a form of showing when it reflects a character’s specific voice and biases rather than just stating facts.

Do I need to show every single detail of a setting?

No. The best showing focuses on a few telling details. Instead of describing every piece of furniture in a room, pick one object that reveals something about the character. A stack of unpaid bills on a mahogany desk tells a story of its own.

Does this rule apply to all genres of fiction?

The principle applies to all fiction, but the execution varies. A fast paced thriller might rely more on telling to keep the speed up, while a literary novel might linger on showing to explore the depths of a character’s psyche.

The journey of learning to show don’t tell is a lifelong one. It is about learning to trust your reader. When you stop explaining everything, you give the reader the space to feel the story for themselves. That trust is what turns a simple narrative into a lasting experience.

Read Michelle's books

Browse books

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *